MPSP Information
Download Problems
Upload Your Solution
Ranking & Analysis
Experiments
Contact Us
Login
E-Mail:
Password:
Forgot your Password?
Register
Experiments
> Experiment: Matheuristics
.: Experiment details
ID
USER
NAME
COMMENT
DATE
DOWNLOAD
24
Túlio Toffolo
Matheuristics
2014-07-02
.: Solutions
Following solutions were submitted to this experiment.
INSTANCES
SOLUTIONS
PERFORMANCE CRITERION:
APD
TMS
DPD
METHOD:
all methods
(C) 1F2B
(D) ABMPSRT
(C) AB_ACS
(C) AB_CACS
(C) AB_CMACS
(C) AB_MACS
(C) AC0+HC+SMT
(C) ACO
(D) ACO+SMT
(C) ACO-HC-CMT
(D) CMAS/ES
(D) CMAS/ES-BORDA
(D) CMAS/ES-STV
(D) CMAS/PROP-STV
(D) CMAS/SA
(C) CP-Sym
(C) DH-MPR
(C) DH/MPR
(C) EDDF
(C) FCFS
(C) Fwd/Bwd
(C) GA-RK
(D) GA-RR/1/B
(C) GA_WS
(C) GenConst
(D) GT-MAS
(C) Gurobi
(C) HYPER
(H) MAS/CG
(H) MAS/CI
(D) MAS/PS
(D) MAS_EVO_DE
(H) MATHEUR
(C) MILP
(C) MINLFT
(C) MINSLK
(C) MINTWK
(C) MRR
(C) PSGSMINSLK
(C) RES
(C) RLS
(C) SASP
(C) Test
(C) WACRU
(D) WPR_GA
ID
INSTANCE
NO. OF
JOBS/PROJ.
NO. OF
PROJ.
NO. OF
GLOB.RES.
OLF
ORIGINATOR
DATE
APD
TMS
DPD
METHOD
EF
CT
1
mp_j30_a10_nr1
30
10
2
5.22409
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
79.7
189
53.4624
MATHEUR
H
0
0
2
mp_j30_a10_nr2
30
10
1
0.893973
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
7.7
109
10.573
MATHEUR
H
0
0
3
mp_j30_a10_nr3
30
10
2
2.64426
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
81.6
250
64.9191
MATHEUR
H
0
0
4
mp_j30_a10_nr4
30
10
3
1.41831
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
16.8
154
25.5899
MATHEUR
H
0
0
5
mp_j30_a10_nr5
30
10
1
1.73196
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
54.2
199
48.7802
MATHEUR
H
0
0
6
mp_j30_a2_nr1
30
2
2
1.17188
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
11.5
77
13.435
MATHEUR
H
1
900
7
mp_j30_a2_nr2
30
2
1
0.85246
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
15
60
11.3137
MATHEUR
H
0
0
8
mp_j30_a2_nr3
30
2
2
0.59375
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
3
65
4.24264
MATHEUR
H
0
0
9
mp_j30_a2_nr4
30
2
3
0.794785
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
10.5
54
7.77817
MATHEUR
H
0
0
10
mp_j30_a2_nr5
30
2
1
0.772014
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
8.5
58
12.0208
MATHEUR
H
0
0
12
mp_j30_a20_nr2
30
20
1
2.24525
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
74.8
287
61.3897
MATHEUR
H
0
0
13
mp_j30_a20_nr3
30
20
2
2.45546
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
96.35
317
75.4148
MATHEUR
H
0
0
14
mp_j30_a20_nr4
30
20
3
1.50719
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
32.75
190
40.5136
MATHEUR
H
0
0
15
mp_j30_a20_nr5
30
20
1
3.51283
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
155.85
445
105.88
MATHEUR
H
0
0
16
mp_j30_a5_nr1
30
5
2
0.829475
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
10.2
87
3.96232
MATHEUR
H
0
0
17
mp_j30_a5_nr2
30
5
1
0.908694
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
12.2
79
7.75887
MATHEUR
H
0
0
18
mp_j30_a5_nr3
30
5
2
1.1125
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
26.4
105
8.11172
MATHEUR
H
0
0
19
mp_j30_a5_nr4
30
5
3
0.274711
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
0
76
0
MATHEUR
H
0
0
20
mp_j30_a5_nr5
30
5
1
1.01263
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
15
94
12.7475
MATHEUR
H
0
0
21
mp_j90_a10_nr1
90
10
2
1.59438
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
49.2
176
24.6297
MATHEUR
H
0
0
22
mp_j90_a10_nr2
90
10
1
0.693411
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
0
128
0
MATHEUR
H
0
0
23
mp_j90_a10_nr3
90
10
2
1.39622
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
42.8
226
31.7098
MATHEUR
H
0
0
24
mp_j90_a10_nr4
90
10
3
0.566283
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
0.7
150
1.33749
MATHEUR
H
0
0
25
mp_j90_a10_nr5
90
10
1
1.47018
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
52.4
278
54.3429
MATHEUR
H
0
0
26
mp_j90_a2_nr1
90
2
2
0.327083
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
0
88
0
MATHEUR
H
0
0
27
mp_j90_a2_nr2
90
2
1
1.02354
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
20
117
22.6274
MATHEUR
H
0
0
28
mp_j90_a2_nr3
90
2
2
0.591108
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
0
114
0
MATHEUR
H
0
0
29
mp_j90_a2_nr4
90
2
3
0.464172
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
0
92
0
MATHEUR
H
0
0
30
mp_j90_a2_nr5
90
2
1
0.429444
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
0
121
0
MATHEUR
H
0
0
31
mp_j90_a20_nr1
90
20
2
0.628208
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
0
97
0
MATHEUR
H
0
0
32
mp_j90_a20_nr2
90
20
1
0.541465
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
2.55
164
4.65069
MATHEUR
H
0
0
33
mp_j90_a20_nr3
90
20
2
0.572828
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
1.2
122
2.94868
MATHEUR
H
0
0
34
mp_j90_a20_nr4
90
20
3
1.14288
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
28.25
195
27.4588
MATHEUR
H
0
0
36
mp_j90_a5_nr1
90
5
2
0.567932
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
0
79
0
MATHEUR
H
0
0
37
mp_j90_a5_nr2
90
5
1
0.54108
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
6
114
10.8397
MATHEUR
H
0
0
38
mp_j90_a5_nr3
90
5
2
0.485698
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
1.6
138
3.57771
MATHEUR
H
0
0
39
mp_j90_a5_nr4
90
5
3
0.792118
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
2.4
123
5.36656
MATHEUR
H
0
0
40
mp_j90_a5_nr5
90
5
1
0.692523
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
12.4
153
17.9805
MATHEUR
H
0
0
41
mp_j120_a10_nr1
120
10
2
1.80118
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
37.2
138
26.343
MATHEUR
H
0
0
42
mp_j120_a10_nr2
120
10
1
1.71096
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
62.9
297
66.4387
MATHEUR
H
0
0
43
mp_j120_a10_nr3
120
10
2
0.750483
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
3.8
142
8.31064
MATHEUR
H
0
0
44
mp_j120_a10_nr4
120
10
3
2.35609
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
182.6
395
78.4675
MATHEUR
H
0
0
46
mp_j120_a2_nr1
120
2
2
1.16651
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
34.5
173
40.3051
MATHEUR
H
0
0
47
mp_j120_a2_nr2
120
2
1
1.02594
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
24
133
15.5563
MATHEUR
H
0
0
48
mp_j120_a2_nr3
120
2
2
2.40115
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
106.5
277
89.8026
MATHEUR
H
0
0
49
mp_j120_a2_nr4
120
2
3
1.3326
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
40
148
11.3137
MATHEUR
H
0
0
50
mp_j120_a2_nr5
120
2
1
0.639792
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
0
108
0
MATHEUR
H
0
0
51
mp_j120_a20_nr1
120
20
2
0.775841
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
2.8
76
0.410391
MATHEUR
H
0
0
52
mp_j120_a20_nr2
120
20
1
0.928796
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
26.15
204
20.551
MATHEUR
H
0
0
53
mp_j120_a20_nr3
120
20
2
0.950353
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
32.8
235
33.9607
MATHEUR
H
0
0
54
mp_j120_a20_nr4
120
20
3
0.960418
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
17.85
203
23.6538
MATHEUR
H
0
0
55
mp_j120_a20_nr5
120
20
1
0.733437
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
15.95
178
12.2752
MATHEUR
H
0
0
56
mp_j120_a5_nr1
120
5
2
0.775841
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
2
75
0
MATHEUR
H
0
0
57
mp_j120_a5_nr2
120
5
1
0.944827
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
24.4
165
30.3035
MATHEUR
H
0
0
58
mp_j120_a5_nr3
120
5
2
1.50214
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
64.2
234
47.5205
MATHEUR
H
0
0
59
mp_j120_a5_nr4
120
5
3
1.4814
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
48.2
197
36.0444
MATHEUR
H
0
0
60
mp_j120_a5_nr5
120
5
1
1.91891
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
71
278
63.4862
MATHEUR
H
0
0
61
mp_j90_a10_nr5_AC1
90
10
4
4.65357
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
254.5
699
189.626
MATHEUR
H
0
0
62
mp_j90_a10_nr5_AC10
90
10
4
2.47298
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
54.4
175
43.998
MATHEUR
H
0
0
65
mp_j90_a10_nr5_AC4
90
10
4
5.12232
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
293.8
667
183.879
MATHEUR
H
0
0
66
mp_j90_a10_nr5_AC5
90
10
4
3.06441
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
129.7
366
87.3487
MATHEUR
H
0
0
67
mp_j90_a10_nr5_AC6
90
10
4
6.6895
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
262.8
693
206.966
MATHEUR
H
0
0
70
mp_j90_a10_nr5_AC9
90
10
4
2.85684
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
81.2
233
57.4723
MATHEUR
H
0
0
72
mp_j90_a20_nr5_AC10
90
20
4
6.99672
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
217.85
494
140.373
MATHEUR
H
0
0
73
mp_j90_a20_nr5_AC2
90
20
4
0.614911
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
0
127
0
MATHEUR
H
0
0
74
mp_j90_a20_nr5_AC3
90
20
4
0.883649
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
10.15
163
12.3257
MATHEUR
H
0
0
76
mp_j90_a20_nr5_AC5
90
20
4
0.948106
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
7.55
124
9.04652
MATHEUR
H
0
0
79
mp_j90_a20_nr5_AC8
90
20
4
1.32622
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
23.5
160
30.4916
MATHEUR
H
0
0
82
mp_j90_a2_nr5_AC10
90
2
4
1.43433
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
21
109
29.6985
MATHEUR
H
0
0
83
mp_j90_a2_nr5_AC2
90
2
4
3.21512
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
176
337
106.066
MATHEUR
H
0
0
84
mp_j90_a2_nr5_AC3
90
2
4
1.55862
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
36.5
160
51.6188
MATHEUR
H
0
0
85
mp_j90_a2_nr5_AC4
90
2
4
3.47215
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
175
329
106.066
MATHEUR
H
0
0
86
mp_j90_a2_nr5_AC5
90
2
4
0.59321
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
0
72
0
MATHEUR
H
0
0
87
mp_j90_a2_nr5_AC6
90
2
4
1.88146
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
66.5
187
44.5477
MATHEUR
H
0
0
88
mp_j90_a2_nr5_AC7
90
2
4
3.41358
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
170.5
330
120.915
MATHEUR
H
0
0
89
mp_j90_a2_nr5_AC8
90
2
4
1.57674
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
38.5
158
53.033
MATHEUR
H
0
0
90
mp_j90_a2_nr5_AC9
90
2
4
3.70676
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
179
329
107.48
MATHEUR
H
0
0
91
mp_j90_a5_nr5_AC1
90
5
4
4.51927
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
230.8
581
175.092
MATHEUR
H
0
0
92
mp_j90_a5_nr5_AC10
90
5
4
3.58582
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
100.2
263
76.5781
MATHEUR
H
0
0
93
mp_j90_a5_nr5_AC2
90
5
4
5.09423
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
268.2
628
211.528
MATHEUR
H
0
0
94
mp_j90_a5_nr5_AC3
90
5
4
2.81893
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
99.4
328
92.235
MATHEUR
H
0
0
95
mp_j90_a5_nr5_AC4
90
5
4
7.29521
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
418.6
816
244.173
MATHEUR
H
0
0
96
mp_j90_a5_nr5_AC5
90
5
4
2.76149
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
88.8
263
69.5751
MATHEUR
H
0
0
97
mp_j90_a5_nr5_AC6
90
5
4
5.53483
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
236
572
177.289
MATHEUR
H
0
0
98
mp_j90_a5_nr5_AC7
90
5
4
5.63617
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
266.2
634
215.429
MATHEUR
H
0
0
99
mp_j90_a5_nr5_AC8
90
5
4
3.37616
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
104.2
325
92.872
MATHEUR
H
0
0
100
mp_j90_a5_nr5_AC9
90
5
4
9.26689
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
428.2
808
247.063
MATHEUR
H
0
0
101
mp_j120_a10_nr5_AC1
120
10
4
5.48558
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
261.8
774
226.412
MATHEUR
H
0
0
102
mp_j120_a10_nr5_AC10
120
10
4
1.39034
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
18.2
192
30.0141
MATHEUR
H
0
0
103
mp_j120_a10_nr5_AC2
120
10
4
3.11209
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
109.4
394
106.897
MATHEUR
H
0
0
105
mp_j120_a10_nr5_AC4
120
10
4
3.21267
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
121.8
427
108.66
MATHEUR
H
0
0
106
mp_j120_a10_nr5_AC5
120
10
4
3.00447
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
91
417
107.046
MATHEUR
H
0
0
108
mp_j120_a10_nr5_AC7
120
10
4
1.28276
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
16.7
145
21.6695
MATHEUR
H
0
0
109
mp_j120_a10_nr5_AC8
120
10
4
1.23125
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
28.4
184
34.0431
MATHEUR
H
0
0
110
mp_j120_a10_nr5_AC9
120
10
4
1.29979
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
17.2
156
21.0122
MATHEUR
H
0
0
121
mp_j120_a2_nr5_AC1
120
2
4
2.49128
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
70
213
91.9239
MATHEUR
H
0
0
122
mp_j120_a2_nr5_AC10
120
2
4
0.864941
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
4
93
5.65685
MATHEUR
H
0
0
123
mp_j120_a2_nr5_AC2
120
2
4
0.934545
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
2.5
104
3.53553
MATHEUR
H
0
0
124
mp_j120_a2_nr5_AC3
120
2
4
1.56043
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
56.5
178
40.3051
MATHEUR
H
0
0
125
mp_j120_a2_nr5_AC4
120
2
4
0.824681
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
3
105
4.24264
MATHEUR
H
0
0
126
mp_j120_a2_nr5_AC5
120
2
4
0.864941
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
5.5
96
7.77817
MATHEUR
H
0
0
127
mp_j120_a2_nr5_AC6
120
2
4
2.62595
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
70.5
212
95.4594
MATHEUR
H
0
0
128
mp_j120_a2_nr5_AC7
120
2
4
0.934545
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
2.5
104
3.53553
MATHEUR
H
0
0
129
mp_j120_a2_nr5_AC8
120
2
4
1.64909
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
58.5
179
45.9619
MATHEUR
H
0
0
130
mp_j120_a2_nr5_AC9
120
2
4
0.824681
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
1.5
96
0.707107
MATHEUR
H
0
0
131
mp_j120_a5_nr5_AC1
120
5
4
4.47621
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
212
599
218.924
MATHEUR
H
0
0
132
mp_j120_a5_nr5_AC10
120
5
4
4.67586
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
200.8
618
212.8
MATHEUR
H
0
0
133
mp_j120_a5_nr5_AC2
120
5
4
2.44252
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
74
298
76.4918
MATHEUR
H
0
0
134
mp_j120_a5_nr5_AC3
120
5
4
3.55733
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
209.8
535
153.698
MATHEUR
H
0
0
135
mp_j120_a5_nr5_AC4
120
5
4
3.13553
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
112.8
379
109.735
MATHEUR
H
0
0
136
mp_j120_a5_nr5_AC5
120
5
4
4.14046
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
193.8
622
209.558
MATHEUR
H
0
0
137
mp_j120_a5_nr5_AC6
120
5
4
5.1924
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
218
591
220.997
MATHEUR
H
0
0
138
mp_j120_a5_nr5_AC7
120
5
4
2.73859
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
82.8
296
83.1066
MATHEUR
H
0
0
139
mp_j120_a5_nr5_AC8
120
5
4
4.176
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
217.4
535
160.223
MATHEUR
H
0
0
140
mp_j120_a5_nr5_AC9
120
5
4
3.43574
Túlio Toffolo
2014-07-02
114.8
374
119.177
MATHEUR
H
0
0
© 2008 Joerg Homberger, HfT Stuttgart